Media Analysis

Navigation instruction: Click on the year you wish to explore.

Key Findings from the Media Analysis

1. Across the three periods, the energy transition (ET) is portrayed as:

  • An inevitable and necessary process, mostly depicted as a future-oriented project.

  • Challenges are mentioned, but in abstract terms.

  • There is a stated need for a just energy transition (JET), though “just” is interpreted from various perspectives.

  • There is no clear definition of what a JET entails or how it should be implemented.

2. Why was it important to study print media in this context?
Print media represents a relatively stable form of discursive production, yet its construction is strongly influenced by the socio-political moment in which it is produced. It does not merely inform; it conveys a particular understanding of a “social fact” (in this case, the energy transition and its implementation) through narration, description, and explanation (Moirand, 2007).

Like any other discourse, media is shaped by and transmits widely accepted values within its context. The press facilitates an interactional exchange between the communicator—here, the author and/or newspaper, acting as an intermediary between political actors/institutions and the public—and the interpreter (the reader).

This interactional exchange implies a communication contract in which journalists report, capture, and explain an event in a specific way (Moirand, 2007). Since it is impossible to report news with complete impartiality, media outlets provide representations of events that reflect prevailing perspectives and opinions—often with the intent of influencing readers’ perceptions of the event (Baker, Gabrielatos & McEnery, 2013).

Through public discourse, various actors seek to influence decision-making and the development of public policy (Isaoho & Markard, 2020). It is no coincidence that in many countries—including Colombia—the owners and executives of media outlets have historically been linked to political and business elites (García Perdomo, 2021).

3. What does this have to do with polarization?

  • There is a noticeable tendency across all periods to positively assess the projects and advances under Duque’s administration, while Petro’s energy transition efforts are evaluated negatively or dismissed. This suggests a certain degree of polarization, particularly in opinion pieces, where alarmist tones and portrayals of the energy transition as a threat are evident. Moreover, the widespread lack of precision—such as in the assessment of implemented measures -can indicate a polarizing discourse, reflecting an intent to exaggerate or downplay the flaws or progress of particular actors.
  • Although the discourse shifts over time, this analysis finds no strong evidence of generalized media-driven polarization. Overall, there is a positive view of the energy transition. However, when the focus turns to specific political leaders and their decisions regarding the transition, some degree of polarization does seem to emerge

As part of the “Polarization and Energy Transition” project led by CREER in Colombia, in collaboration with the Ford Foundation, we conducted a media analysis covering both national and regional outlets. The monitoring included approximately 110 print media sources, 1,119 online outlets, 19 television channels, and 95 radio stations, focusing on 14 key concepts related to the energy transition.

Specifically, a discourse analysis was carried out using written sources, applying a corpus linguistics methodology. For this analysis, a total of 956 articles comprising 575,848 words were collected. These articles were published between June 2021 and June 2023 across more than 30 different platforms and newspapers.

It is important to note that this analysis placed special emphasis on media content produced in the departments of Cesar and La Guajira, as they have become central to Colombia’s energy transition. These regions are not only the core of the country’s largest mining economies and coal exports, but also the primary sites for the development of renewable energy projects. Furthermore, they have been prioritized in recent years within government agendas and public policy frameworks on this issue.

Working Sector

Report from the meeting with workers and trade unions

Testimony from workers and trade unions

Closures and multi-stakeholder dialogue

Full document

Executive summary

Transitional minerals

The rapid expansion of critical minerals for the energy transition and other strategic industries (agriculture, defense, technology) presents us with a paradox: the decarbonization of the planet depends on an intensification of mining activity. For CREER, this rapid expansion carries critical risks regarding human rights, local economic dynamics, and ecosystem balance. Our work focuses on analyzing these dilemmas through the lens of a just transition, promoting governance frameworks that mitigate negative impacts and ensure that the mining of “minerals for the future” is carried out under rigorous standards of sustainability, equity, and respect for fundamental rights, through dialogue among different stakeholders.

Energy Communities

We analyze the governance and sustainability challenges that arise in the implementation of decentralized generation models. Our work focuses on researching how local associative structures interact with regulatory frameworks and human rights standards. Through applied research, we assess the risks of rent capture, internal decision-making conflicts, and the conditions necessary for these self-management schemes to guarantee equitable and transparent participation in the territory.

Solar

With a focus on responsible land management and respect for local livelihoods, at CREER we apply our technical expertise in the photovoltaic sector to promote a solar transition with social integrity. Through the analysis of rural environments, the strengthening of local governance, and the design of participation mechanisms, we seek to ensure that large-scale deployment in Latin America not only contributes to the energy mix, but also strengthens the social fabric. Our purpose is to lead due diligence models that ensure solar infrastructure coexists with food security, strategic ecosystems, and the productive vocations of each community.

Resources for Territorial Planning

Peacebuilding, Citizen Participation, and Human Rights

Transformative Perspectives for a Just Energy Transition